Skip to content
Saturday, November 7, 2026
Journal Online 360

My Proposal to Reform the Academy System and Help Young Players

A standout among the favourite moments of the season came recently, watching a promising starlet charge up the pitch from his defensive box to seal a decisive finish.

Young players are always celebrated by their team's followers and, from what I've seen, the fanbase are likely to enjoy many more special performances from him in the years to follow.

Yet, for each player who makes it, there are countless of other aspiring footballers who fail to progress beyond the different levels, and have to deal with a crushing rejection at a young age.

It is this group who drop out of academy football that I am concerned about, because I don't think the present framework is sufficient to inform them about their odds, or support them when they are let go.

It demands an transformation and, when I left management, I compiled my own analysis into the youth development pathway, including suggestions for how it could be bettered.

An Huge Commitment – Yielding Certain Major Benefits

The outlook on youth setups is not only as a ex- manager. My family members are in the programme, so I've got a direct interest too.

For all aspiring footballers, the goal of becoming a pro player is a special one. The youth development framework has been established to give them the optimal chance to realise that ambition, with a formal plan being launched over a decade ago.

Presently, many thousands of boys are in the setup, at teams from the top flight down. It's an demanding set-up, with training at least three nights a week and a fixtures schedule that occupies most of their weekends.

The equivalent framework is now being used by the rapidly expanding sport, girls football, too.

These academies are staffed at exceptional levels and provide work for coaches, physiotherapists, doctors and many more backroom staff.

The infrastructure are of the top quality, with excellent indoor and outdoor fields. Schooling is provided too, with tutors employed to run mandatory educational programmes.

The financial commitment is vast but, as we have observed, the clubs at the pinnacle are reaping significant benefits on that outlay through loans and transfers of the academy-produced players.

How is the Existing Framework?

The main performance plan has been in effect for almost 15 years now, so how has it performed to the passage of time?

Academies now run a pre-academy programme for kids from the age of six, so if any of them complete the full programme they would graduate at 21. That's more time than a child spends in mainstream education, and covers his entire childhood.

These children are issued with club tracksuits and coats, all branded up, and are identified by friends and family as being associated with that club.

Their identity has, effectively, been imprinted on them at a tender age and they also have to make a full dedication to the academy programme.

That means coaching on three evenings a week, and a fixtures schedule taking up most of the weekend, are now a key component of a youngster's aim to follow his ambition.

From my findings, in many cases what happens at their studies is seen as being less important, with the academy assuming primary importance and evolving into the main focus of the child and his family's life.

A number of families see a pot of gold at the end of the journey if their child makes it and put enormous pressure on their shoulders to succeed.

Sadly, figures show the system has a total disparity of success and failure. We all see the stars, but we rarely see those who fail.

Be Honest About Their Prospects

I have no desire to strip those aspirations away from young players but we have to be pragmatic with them about their prospects.

While there are specific individuals a club will target as being potential professionals, the reality is a significant proportion of the players have only been on the pathway to fill the spots needed for training sessions and the weekend games at each age group.

I genuinely don't feel academies sufficiently manage the expectations of these players or families, about where they sit in the wider system.

Players and parents should be given a comprehensive assessment of where they rate, so they can manage for the likely letdown when it occurs.

Our academies have nurtured some fantastic players and there is more focus paid to player wellbeing now than in the past, but let's also bring in a bit more emphasis on transparency too.

Greater Emphasis on Academics

As I noted above, I think many youth players joining academies in fact listen more closely of their coaches at times than they do of their teachers.

It's important this is recognised within the academy system, and youth directors communicate this principle to the coaches at each age group.

This situation itself is long-standing. Tutelage played a significant part in my development, and sports teachers and coaches were always held in high esteem.

But, for those running an academy, they must ensure the coaches are given unambiguous guidance and understanding of their role because of the influence they have.

Principles of decorum, discipline and hard work should be as demanding as they are in any school environment – and should apply to the scholastic side of the child's life there too.

The system I have suggested would have greater weight on studies and mentoring – for guardians as well as the youth players – and also support for what follows if they are let go aged 16.

The Proposal to Help Young Players

I would place academies within six regions, each overseen by a manager and link them with partner schools and colleges.

Before they get to apprenticeship level, players would be evaluated at 14 to see what learning track fits them.

At 16, players taking scholarships would register in a compulsory dual academic programme with the educational partners.

Concurrently, the players who are let go at 16, can begin a full-on combined educational programme with the schools or colleges.

The advantage for them would be the provision of a new competitive programme where the schools and colleges would

About the author

Elizabeth Barnes

A seasoned journalist with over a decade of experience covering technology and current affairs across the UK.

Journal Online 360

Type to search articles.